353 words
2 minutes
A Kindness That Isn't Purely Kind
Views

Today I saw a video: a parent could not understand why a school would ask second-graders to donate money. Asking primary-school children, who have no income of their own, to donate is unreasonable.

It brought back something from over ten years ago, when I was in third grade and donated too. The teacher projected a few photos on a screen: a child barely older than us, seriously ill, raising money for treatment. In the photos he looked to be suffering, worn down by the illness. The teacher told us we would donate the next day and that the amount was up to us. The class monitor came around recording names and amounts.

Back home I told my mother about it, got five yuan out of her, and donated the whole of it the next day. Then I thought it over and donated the one yuan of pocket money I had with me as well. The figure next to my name on the donation sheet went from five yuan to six.

When it was over, my classmates were talking about how the monitor of the class next door had given a hundred yuan, and so-and-so fifty. I felt a little ashamed, ashamed that I had not given more.

Later the teacher read out the names of the students who had given five yuan and had everyone applaud, because five yuan counted as a small fortune to a child. But I had given six, so my name was never read out. A good deed done, but anonymously.

What I was thinking at the time was probably this: if I had not given that extra one yuan, would my name have been called and would I have been praised? But then I felt I was too calculating, donating in order to be named.

Looking back now, human nature is always complicated, and there is no doing anything without some self-interested motive. As a child what I cared about was whether my name was called. Only later did I understand that the truly hard question is not whether I was calculating, but whether kindness has to be seen before it counts for anything.

A Kindness That Isn't Purely Kind
https://blog.thulaw.top/en/posts/not-purely-kind/
Author
Boran
Published at
2026-10-15
License
CC BY-NC-SA 4.0

Comments